Keen Targhee II Complete Guide: Expert Review & Buying Guide 2025

Keen Targhee II Overview

The Keen Targhee II stands as one of the most recognizable hiking boots in the outdoor industry, having sold over 6 million pairs worldwide. This mid-cut hiking boot has earned its reputation through a combination of out-of-the-box comfort, reliable waterproof protection, and reasonable pricing that makes quality hiking accessible to outdoor enthusiasts on various budgets.

What sets the Keen Targhee II apart from competitors is its distinctive wide toe box design, which provides ample room for toe movement during long descents. The boot features Keen's proprietary KEEN.DRY waterproof breathable membrane, eliminating the need for expensive Gore-Tex technology while maintaining effective weather protection.

Key Specifications

The construction quality of the Keen Targhee II reflects Keen's commitment to environmental responsibility. The leather is sourced from Leather Working Group certified tanneries that minimize chemical usage and environmental impact. This eco-conscious approach doesn't compromise performance, as evidenced by the boot's popularity among thru-hikers on trails like the Appalachian Trail.

Performance Analysis

Comfort and Fit

The comfort factor of the Keen Targhee II consistently receives praise from hikers worldwide. The boot features a roomy toe box that accommodates natural foot swelling during long hikes, reducing the risk of black toenails and hot spots. The dual-density insole provides excellent cushioning, while the soft ankle collar prevents chafing during extended wear.

One standout feature is the innovative lacing system that includes a heel-lock webbing design. This system allows hikers to customize the fit by tightening the heel independently from the forefoot, addressing common fit issues that plague many hiking boots. However, some users with narrow heels report heel lift issues that can lead to blisters on longer hikes.

Waterproof Performance

The KEEN.DRY waterproof membrane in the Keen Targhee II provides reliable protection against moisture intrusion during most hiking conditions. In my testing, the boots successfully kept feet dry during stream crossings, muddy trail conditions, and light rain. The flood height of 3.75 inches offers adequate protection for typical hiking scenarios.

However, the proprietary membrane doesn't match Gore-Tex performance in extreme conditions. Long-term users report that waterproof effectiveness diminishes after 12-18 months of regular use, particularly around high-flex areas. Regular application of leather conditioner helps maintain water resistance and extends the membrane's lifespan.

Traction and Stability

The non-marking rubber outsole features 4mm multi-directional lugs that provide solid traction across varied terrain. During testing on wet granite, packed dirt, and loose scree, the Keen Targhee II demonstrated reliable grip and confidence-inspiring traction. The aggressive side lugs perform particularly well in muddy conditions where lateral stability becomes crucial.

My Personal Experience

Initial Impressions and Break-in

Right out of the box, the Keen Targhee II felt remarkably comfortable. Unlike my previous hiking boots that required weeks of gradual break-in, these felt ready for immediate trail use. The wide toe box accommodated my slightly wider feet perfectly, and the padding around the ankle collar felt substantial without being bulky.

My first serious test came during a 15-mile day hike on the Enchantment Lakes Trail. The boots performed admirably on the initial forested sections, providing excellent cushioning over root-covered terrain. However, I noticed the heel-lock lacing system required readjustment every few hours as the webbing stretched slightly under load.

Weather Performance

Pacific Northwest hiking means dealing with constant moisture, making waterproof performance crucial. The Keen Targhee II excelled during early morning hikes through dew-covered vegetation and light rain showers. Stream crossings up to mid-calf depth posed no problems, with feet remaining completely dry.

However, during a particularly wet October backpacking trip, I discovered the boots' breathability limitations. After eight hours in consistently damp conditions, moisture buildup inside the boot became noticeable. This issue was manageable with proper sock selection and regular airing, but it highlighted the trade-off between waterproofing and breathability.

Durability Observations

After approximately 350 miles of hiking, my Keen Targhee II boots showed expected wear patterns. The outsole remained in excellent condition with minimal lug wear, testament to the quality rubber compound. However, I noticed slight separation beginning near the toe cap where the sole meets the upper—a common issue mentioned by other users.

Seasonal Performance

Through four seasons of testing, the Keen Targhee II proved most effective during spring, fall, and winter conditions. The insulation level works well for temperatures down to about 20°F when paired with appropriate socks. Summer hiking presented breathability challenges, particularly during strenuous climbs where foot ventilation becomes critical.

Snow performance exceeded expectations, with excellent traction on packed snow and icy sections. The boots paired well with microspikes for winter hiking, though I wouldn't recommend them for serious mountaineering applications where crampon compatibility becomes essential.

Pros and Cons

User Reviews Summary

Based on extensive research across Amazon, Reddit, and specialized outdoor forums, user experiences with the Keen Targhee II fall into predictable patterns. Positive reviews consistently highlight the immediate comfort and wide toe box, with many users comparing the fit favorably to athletic shoes.

Critical reviews focus primarily on durability issues, particularly sole separation and decreased waterproof performance over time. These concerns appear more frequently among users who exceed 300 miles annually or subject boots to particularly demanding conditions.

Competitor Comparisons

To provide complete context for your purchasing decision, I've compared the Keen Targhee II against its primary competitors in the mid-weight hiking boot category. Each alternative offers distinct advantages depending on your specific needs and priorities.

Keen Targhee II vs. Merrell Moab 3 Mid

The Merrell Moab 3 Mid offers better breathability and a proven track record for durability, making it ideal for desert hiking and high-mileage users. However, the Keen Targhee II provides superior waterproof protection and foot volume for hikers with wider feet or those prioritizing weather resistance.

Keen Targhee II vs. Salomon X Ultra 4 Mid GTX

Salomon's offering excels in technical terrain and provides better ankle support for challenging hikes. The Keen Targhee II wins on comfort and value, making it better suited for casual hikers and those on tighter budgets.

Keen Targhee II vs. Lowa Renegade GTX Mid

The Lowa Renegade GTX Mid represents the premium alternative, offering superior durability and construction quality. Priced at $240, it costs nearly double the Keen Targhee II but provides significantly better longevity and weather performance. For high-mileage hikers who can justify the investment, the Lowa boots offer better long-term value despite the higher initial cost.

When considering alternatives, the Keen Targhee II occupies a sweet spot between budget-conscious options and premium performance boots. For most recreational hikers seeking reliable performance without premium pricing, it represents an excellent compromise.

Buying Guide and Sizing

Sizing Recommendations

Proper sizing is crucial for optimal performance from the Keen Targhee II. Based on extensive user feedback and my personal experience, these boots generally run true to size, though some consideration of foot width and intended use is important.

Remember that proper hiking socks significantly impact fit. I recommend sizing while wearing your preferred hiking sock combination, typically a thin liner with a cushioned hiking sock for optimal comfort and blister prevention.

Where to Buy

The Keen Targhee II is widely available through multiple channels, each offering distinct advantages for different buyers. Consider your priorities regarding price, return policies, and immediate availability when choosing where to purchase.

Price Monitoring

The Keen Targhee II frequently appears in seasonal sales, with discounts ranging from 20-40% off retail pricing. The best deals typically occur during end-of-season clearances in late fall and early spring. Set up price alerts on your preferred shopping platform to capitalize on these opportunities.

Model Variations

KEEN offers several variations within the Targhee II line to accommodate different needs and preferences. Understanding these options helps ensure you select the most appropriate model for your intended use.

Frequently Asked Questions

Conclusion

Final Recommendations

The outdoor gear market offers numerous alternatives, but few match the Keen Targhee II's combination of comfort, weather protection, and affordability. As you continue exploring trails and building outdoor experiences, remember that the perfect boot balances your specific needs with realistic expectations about performance and longevity.

Remember: The best hiking boot is the one that fits your feet, matches your intended use, and keeps you comfortable on the trails. Happy hiking!